V. Amod Saxena
Presented to
the
Copyright © 2006
V. Amod Saxena
I met her early 1970s, in the hospital library. I had gone
there one morning to look up an article for a lecture I was to give that afternoon.
The place was quiet. There, I saw Ona Dangus, an internist at the hospital
standing between two rows of tall bookshelves. She was reading a medical
journal with a red cover. As soon as she saw me, she put the journal
back on the shelf and gave me a smile.
“Are you our
new cancer doctor?” She asked.
She was petite
and wore a loose white lab-coat that seemed to cover her entire body from her shoulders
to her knees. She had dark brown hair peppered with silver gray. She had kept
her hair short that accented her large medium brown eyes. The skin of her face
had a soft texture that seemed to shine in the artificial light in the room. I thought
that she was probably in her mid fifties. The half-moon reading glasses rested on tip of
her short and pointed nose. There was a
small black mole on her left temple. She
seemed kindly, gentle and friendly.
“Dr. Dangus, I
have heard about you. Yes, I joined the hospital last week.” I replied. I shyly extended my right hand forwards to
shake hers. She took my hand with both
of hers and gripped it firmly.
“Welcome to
the hospital! We need you here. I almost
called you last night about one of my patients.” She said.
Ona had grown
up in
Ona’s uncle Egon
and his wife Dorothy had no children of their own. Egon had come to
When the owner
of the factory died suddenly one day, his widow asked Egon to manage the business.
Finally, he bought her out and became a proud owner of the company. He was
convinced that his success was due to Ona presence in his home. She brought him
luck, he would often say. Every evening, he would go in Ona’s room on his
return from work and spend time just being with her, talking and comparing
their days’ activities. This was the
most precious time together for both of them.
Ona continued to work for the physician and enjoyed her job. She
would clean the place every day and help the doctor in his office. There was no other employee in the office.
Between the doctor and Ona, the patients received their medical care. Ona had even learnt to take blood pressure
and blood and urine samples. There was also an X-ray machine that the doctor
operated himself. Soon, Ona learnt to operate the machine also. When the doctor
was busy, she would take X-ray pictures of his patients. Often, he would do
fluoroscopy on his patients with suspected tuberculosis. She would help set up the patient behind the
screen and together, they would look at their chest. Live anatomy of the
patients under the X-rays intrigued Ona. The ribs, the spine and the motion of heart
and lung behind the screen fascinated her. She enjoyed watching the dance of
the arteries and veins.
She too wanted
to be a physician. She loved her work, loved to talk to patients and felt deep
satisfaction in helping people. After majoring in European history, she entered
a medical school in
She completed residency training in internal
medicine at a local German hospital in southeast side of
Once, a loud
knock at her door in the middle of night woke her up. When she looked outside,
she saw a woman in her nightgown standing there pleading to see her. She
immediately recognized her as one of her patients. Apparently, earlier that
night, her husband, while drunk, beat her and gave her a black eye. She came to
Ona for help. She invited the woman in,
kept her in her own house for two weeks, and nursed her. Her husband, one evening
came to Ona’s office complaining of chest pain. The man had lost weight and
looked drained. He had not eaten well and had trouble sleeping. Ona found
nothing physically wrong with him. She then
enquired about his wife; he broke down and cried. Ona did not tell him the
whereabouts of his wife. It was only
after he promised that he would never raise his hands on his wife again that
she offered her services to help find his wife. And so she did.
In
1944, Ona met a young man named John Kagan. He had gone to a law school but
could not find work as a lawyer. He lived in the neighborhood. He did odd jobs
to keep himself busy and earn a little money. He wanted to be a successful
lawyer and someday a judge. He was tall and athletic with dark hair and tanned
skin. He usually dressed himself in a dark suite, a starched white shirt and a
bow tie. One could see him often walking in the neighborhood. One day he saw
Ona carrying heavy bags of grocery. He offered his help to carry them to her
home. She was immediately attracted to
his looks. His kindness overwhelmed
her. They began to spend time together, walking hand in hand, shopping and
attending the neighborhood German church. They both loved baseball and often went to
While Ona was
busy, starting her medical practice, John, still without regular work, helped
her set her clinic. Ona often teased him about his bow tie. She told him that
his bow tie was a distraction that prevented him from getting a job. One day, John met an old woman who complained that
her landlord was giving her trouble. He had an offer of a larger monthly rent for
his apartment and thus wanted to evict the woman on some false pretense. She
had no place to go if evicted. John offered to represent her free of cost. He
convinced the owner to let the woman stay in her apartment. The word of the
incident got out and thus, John started his law practice. Soon Ona and her
husband had a busy practice. They had three daughters soon after that.
My friendship
with Ona grew. I found her a gentle, caring and hard working physician. She
also loved to read, mostly books on European history. John was quiet but nor
introverted. I never saw them argue. I
spent a lot of time with her and her family. I witnessed her daughters grow up
to be young women. The family included
me in most important family events. My own life was going on peacefully with a
busy medical practice and teaching. Often, Ona would try to match me with some
of her friends or their friends but without much success.
One morning in 1982, I was leisurely walking to the
hospital. It was beautiful day in early spring. The sun was bright and warm
with the high-pressure front that had stayed on for several days over the
When I reached
the floor, they were putting Ona on a hospital bed. Several doctors and nurses
surrounded her. She had intravenous drip running in her left arm. Electrocardiogram
wires were attached to her chest and legs.
She seemed awake but quiet. I walked quickly towards her, touched her
forehead, and felt her pulse to see if she was all right. She smiled and told
me that every thing was fine. She just had a little dizziness and they were
making a big fuss about nothing.
That morning,
she had just started round of her patients in the hospital. One of the senior
nurses was with her. Since she was a hesitant teacher, only a few resident
doctors went with her on these rounds. On these rounds, Ona was forbearing with
her patients. She would walk in the room and sit down before asking about their
condition. She spent considerable time talking to them about their family, the
neighborhood and other things that did not always had any connection to their
medical condition. The young residents resented this as just a waste of their
time.However, the patients looked forwards to this visit every day.
This morning,
Ona had just finished talking to one of her patients, an obese woman with
diabetes and high blood pressure. She gave her a stern advice about her diet. She was now giving her a home tried recipe for
losing weight when, suddenly she felt strange light-headedness. She felt her whole
body being suspended in air. She began to sweat and felt a sudden chill in the
air; image of her patient in front began to blur. The room seemed to revolve
and objects in front began to dim. The nurse next to her noticed that something
was wrong with Ona, quickly grabbed her before she could fall. She then slowly lowered her on a nearby chair.
Ona recovered
quickly and told the nurse not to worry. She had been rather tired and needed a
vacation, she told the nurse and her patient. She insisted on continuing but
the nurse declined her request.
Instead, she
called the operator to page “Dr. Red” that would bring immediate help for a
medical emergency. Quite quickly, the
hospital’s Emergency Response Team arrived and took over Ona’s care.
They admitted her
under the care of Dr. Jacob Black, an internist with practice mostly limited to
hematology. This was just as well because he found Ona to be severely anemic. He told her later that normally a human being could
not carry much physical activity at this level of anemia. Ona on the other
hand, carried a full load of a busy medical practice. Her blood also showed a large number of
immature white blood cells when seen under a microscope. This was a definite sign of acute leukemia. Her
bone marrow examination confirmed the diagnosis of Acute Leukemia.
I went to see
her in the hospital next day. A notice posted on her hospital room asked
visitors not to disturb her. Below the notice, I wrote a personal note
“Get well
soon, Ona, we miss you”.
That evening,
Ona phoned me at home. Her voice was slow and distant. She spoke in a low soft
voice.
“I wanted to
talk to you. That notice on my door was not for you. I must talk to you,” I
could feel in her tone of voice a little irritation and disappointment.
She insisted,
“When would I see you?”
“Ona, you need
rest and talking to visitors is exhausting. I shall come and see you first
thing tomorrow morning. You should take care of yourself. I have talked Jacob; he
tells me that everything is fine and you need not worry.” I said trying to
cheer her up.
“My blood and
bone marrow is full of myeloblasts. I also have a low-grade fever. I woke up
sweating this afternoon. My bed sheets got wet. Last week I bumped my arm
against the doorknob and it gave me a big bruise. That day I ignored it. Now I
know why. My platelet count is low.”
“Ona, Don’t
worry, everything will be fine. There are things we can do for acute leukemia. We
have good treatments for it.” I lied to her. I knew well that the prognosis was
poor for such patients.
“Who are you
kidding, doctor? That is not your honest
opinion. I need your help, not your pity.
My age, anemia, a large spleen, low platelets, a bone marrow full of blast
cells, do not look good to me. How could I have missed the spleen? It comes
down to my belly button.” She sounded as if she was giving me details about a
patient of her not about herself.
I said little and
put the phone down after promising to see her first thing in the morning. I slept fretfully that night. In my
experience, I had never seen patient similar to Ona survive long. Only a
miracle would now save her.
I had gone to
a medical convention and thus, did not see Ona for a whole week. When I
returned I spoke to Jacob about Ona. He said that Ona was hanging in there. He
had given her several pints of blood to stop her bruises. It also brought her
hemoglobin up. He started her on a
course of intensive chemotherapy. She seems to be tolerating the treatment as
well as expected.
Her hospital
room was on the seventh floor. It was the oncology floor. Each nurse cared for
only two patients here. Each bed on this floor was hooked up to the most modern
equipment. When I entered her room, she was
sitting on a large chair with several pillows behind her back for support. They
were transfusing her blood and a clear yellow fluid. She had fallen asleep with her head tilted
back on the pillow. Her mouth was half-open and the lips had dried up. She was
breathing quietly.
I sat down on a
chair next to her bed. Sunshine filtered
through the window glass at a sharp angle in the room. The sunlight on her face
sharpened her features. She looked pale and at least twenty years older. Her
hair had grayed in a hurry and her eyes sank deep into their sockets. Patches
of black and blue bruises covered her both arms. She looked as if she had been
in a fistfight with some one and lost. In her left hand she held, reading
glasses.
On the wall in
front of her bed a group photographs hung. There was Ona, slim and trim with a
broad smile. She held an infant in her
lap and next to her was a handsome man in a dark suit. Another young girl about
seven years old stood in front of Ona. A third girl of about eight or nine
stood on the left side of her. I was sure that the photo was taken in happier
days of her life some years ago.
She slowly opened
her eyes and gawked at me for a few seconds. I was not sure if she recognized
me.
I brought my
chair closer to hers and gently took her left hand in mine, pushing her glasses
on one side. She kept her gaze at me.
“Ona, it is
me.” I said softly afraid to startle her.
“I know! Good to see you. I am so glad you came.” She
whispered squeezing my hand.
She turned her
head towards me while covering her half-naked breasts with her nightgown. She kept looking at me. She had definitely lost weight and looked washed-out.
How could all this happen so suddenly? I thought.
“I still have
pain but feel stronger now. I wish I could go in a coma never to wake up again.
Have you talked to John? He is the sick
one in the family. I worry about him. I don’t think he can manage by himself.” She
spoke softly.
She turned her
head and shifted her eye towards the picture on the wall still holding my hand.
She told me that the picture was taken in
“We had a
wonderful time there. The older girls wanted to ride the horses but were afraid
to get on them. John rode with them one by one. We all had fun. They were good times. She
became quiet and sank her head in the pillow under her head. I began to massage
the bruise over the back of her hand.
“This pain over
my body; I have hard time lifting things. My arms feel heavy and my shoulders
hurt. Last night, I was cold and wanted to cover my face with the blanket. It
was hard. I never thought that I would suffer like this.
“When I was a
young woman, I wanted to be a doctor, marry a perfect man, have a big house in
“Nothing
prepared me for this. I have a lot of
pain”. She seemed miserable.
“Why don’t you
take pain medication, Ona?” I said
“No, I do not
want pain killers. They are just crutches. I can do without them.” She said.
She closed her
eyes. She looked tired. Her voice trailed off. I let go of her hand and quietly
left the room.
I slept poorly
that night. I worried about Ona’s illness. She was dying. Only a few hours ago,
Jacob had confided to me that Ona had not responded to the drugs and he might
have to try second line of drugs. They did not work as well. That was a bad news.
Next day was a
Friday; it was cool and breezy. The spring that year was cooler than usual. The
trees would soon begin to grow leaf-buds. Crocuses were just begun to sprout. It would
be a few more weeks before the warmer weather would come. I found Ona sitting
up in her bed resting her torso on pillows. A meal tray sat on a table in front;
she had eaten most of her breakfast. She was sipping coffee from a plastic cup.
She seemed
cheerful that morning. She still looked frail and had a mild wheeze. The temperature chart showed that she was
running a low-grade fever. I sat down next to her on an easy chair facing
her. I kept quiet.
“What is
wrong? You look sad today.” She said.
“I don’t know.
It is hard for me to think clearly.” I said.
“Why?”
“Because, I am
worried about you. I don’t understand all this about your illness”
“Why worry
about me. You know, this is it, for me.”
“How can you
be so relaxed about it? Why are you not angry?
“Come and sit
down next to me on the bed.” She said. I rolled the breakfast table away from her and
sat down next to her on the bed. She put her arms around me and gently pulled me
towards her to give me a hug. Her body was warm. I moved closure to her mostly
for my own comfort. My eyes were wet and I felt a knot in my throat. She cupped
my head between her two hands brought it close and planted a soft kiss on my
lips and cheeks. I stayed in that position, unable to move. I also, did not
want to show my sorrow.
“Look, I was angry
when I found out that I had leukemia. Two day ago, I finally told my husband as
plainly as I could about this. He just kept quiet. The news probably shocked
him. He got up and walked away without saying a word to me. He still has not accepted the diagnosis. He does not want to talk about it to me.” She
said sadly.
John’s silence
hurt her immensely. She wanted to tell him many things before she died but
found it impossible to bring up the subject of her death. He refused to discuss
her death. I kept quiet. I knew that she had a happy married life. I liked
John. He was good man. He was quiet and compassionate.
“After the
girls were born, I lost all interest in sex. We have not had sex, at least for
ten years. We both have been busy and there was no time for each other. John never
made demands. He left me alone. Love needs
good communication as much as physical relationship to grow. Here, I lie with
life incomplete with lot of regrets. I
kept telling myself that when I get some time away from my busy practice, I
would make it up to him in a big way. Now, I feel in the wrong telling him that
I love him. I he is resentful of my neglect of his needs”
“Ona, please
stop blaming yourself? You will be fine.” I said. She did not seem to pay any
attention to me. She kept talking still holding me in her arms. Our fatalistic conversation
was upsetting me a little. Yet, I wanted
to explore the subject with her. I wondered if she had any idea of death.
“Death is just another part of life; you are born to die one
day.”
“Can you
really take dying so lightly? It makes me angry to see you die so young.” I
said pulling myself away from her.
“There is
never a good time to die. Some die young; others die at a ripe old age. Some
die peacefully and others die in pain and suffering. Yet, some die horribly. I
just want to die peacefully. Today, I feel well because the pain is less; I
would rather die now before the pain returns, but time of dying is not in my
hands.”
“You are an
angel and God has a special place for you. Moreover, you are not going to die.”
I said.
“Stop calling
me an angel. You know nothing about my life.” She said with irritation.
“You have a
good soul. We all have a soul. It makes us what we are. The body is just a physical
being, a god given attire; the soul changes its clothes after death. It never
dies, Ona.” I responded.
“You are
talking about rebirth. It does not happen. When the body stops working, it dies
and that is the end of it.”
“You will
always be my friend, Ona? Even after death.” I said.
“I will come
and haunt you in your dreams.” She said teasingly.
“Seriously,
Ona; do you believe in life after death?
“No, I do not.
Once we are gone, we are gone forever. Some of my friends believe that there is
heaven and hell after death. If you ask me, hell is right here on earth; I went
through hell the last few days. Today, I feel great and I have a better
understanding of my situation. I am ready to die. I will have to answer god for
my deeds on earth.”
“Ona, just
think, god made this earth and all of us. He sent us here to experience life.
We do both good and bad things. I think god is forgiving; he would never punish
us. Some of our suffering is caused by
our own deeds here and also in our previous life.”
“You believe
in rebirth?” She exclaimed at me.
“I do not know
if I truly believe in rebirth. If I did not, I would find life hard to live.” I said.
I did not want
to upset Ona in her situation and so I stopped the subject and said nothing
more. I did not want this conversation
of life and death to upset Ona. She looked at me tenderly and lightly brushed
my hand.
“We all die one day and we all have to answer for our actions
on earth.” She said with a serious face. I kept quiet. She seemed tired and I
told her to rest. I put my hand on her forehead and gently coaxed her to lie
down. She closed her eyes and I could see her chest moving slowly up and down
with each breath. I felt her pulse; it was strong and regular. I then turned
the lights off and quietly left her room, closing the door behind me.
I went to bed without
dinner that night. I had lost my
appetite. I dreamt of a fierce storm around me. There was this large body of water that
surrounded me. I stood on a long and narrow bridge that snaked in front of me without
an end. The water splashed powerfully, and
tried to uproot me off the bridge. I hung on to its railing. I tried to walk but felt powerless. Large bodies
some with wings and others resembling missiles with short fins flew over me with
lightening speed. Strong wind, flying objects and fearsome missiles above and around
me were terrifying. When one of the objects was about to crash on me, I
suddenly opened my eyes to find myself in a catatonic state. A few seconds
passed and then I noticed the window of my bedroom and through it, a large full
moon hung in the clear sky. I slowly moved my arms and cross them over my chest.
My heart was pounding and I was sweating.
Next day, I went to see Ona again, she was lying in her bed
writhing in pain. She told me that her pain was unbearable. I came out of her
room and found the nurse taking care of her. I asked her about pain medication.
The nurse told me that Ona refused the pain medication and forbade any one from
giving any medication without her knowledge.
I went back to Ona’s room. She looked up and tried to talk to
me; she could only whisper, the pain was too much for her to talk. Even a
small movement of her body hurt her, tightening her muscles.
“Ona, what’s wrong with
you? Why don’t you take pain medication? You know that it will help you.” I asked.
She took a deep breath and then asked if I believed in mercy? I
said, of course I did. I did not want to strike an argument with her. I just wanted
to persuade her to take the painkillers. She seemed to gather her strength and
said to me,
“It is better to suffer in hell here than to go to hell after I
am dead.” She tried to force a smile. I could see the pain on her face.
“Ona, you have helped many sick people in your life. You cared
for your family; you are a good woman. Why do you want to suffer?”
She kept quiet for several seconds. When she opened her mouth
to speak, she was clear and firm.
“You do not understand.”
“You worry yourself too much? I have known you for many years. I
know how much good you have done in your life. God loves people like you.
Moreover, do not talk about death; you will soon be well and back to your work.” I tried to console her.
“I am dying and it will not be too long before my suffering
will end. Come and sit down. Talk to me. Do you remember, I told you about the
doctor I worked for when I was young? He had an X-ray machine. He used to take
X-ray pictures of patients to look for tuberculosis in their lungs. ”
“Yes, I do
remember you telling me all about him. He was exposing his patients and you
with unwanted radiation. I should know,
I have seen and heard about the X-ray machines in those days.” I said rather
bluntly but refrained from telling her that in my opinion, her leukemia might
have been caused by overexposure to radiation at the doctor’s office. No one knows
the amount of radiation she received while working there.
She said
nothing for a while and closed her eyes but slowly recovered her composure. I began
to understand her difficulties, past memories and her fears of not being at
peace with herself. Although, her mental status seemed well, her past seemed to
be haunting her emotionally. I promised myself that I would spend some time
with her daily until the very end of her life. I kept my word. She only lived for three more weeks after that
conversation. During this time, she
talked to me a great deal, sometimes clearly but later at the end of her life, she just
rambled.
She told me
about a seventeen years old girl. Her mother, a patient of hers, brought her to
see Ona. A few hoodlums in the neighborhood
had gang raped the daughter. The mother was concerned that the girl might be
pregnant. She was afraid of reporting
the crime to the police. Ona admitted her in the hospital with a diagnosis of
excessive bleeding and pain in the abdomen. That night she took the girl to the
operating room, evacuated her womb, and confirmed that she was in fact pregnant.
Ona never reported the pregnancy. When
she discharged the girl, she told her and her mother that she was not
pregnant. Lately, the unborn baby kept
coming in her dreams and troubling her.
Ona also told me about a patient that had been bothering her. This
was an eighty-year-old man who had an advanced Parkinson’s disease. He suffered
from uncontrolled shakes and pains. Ona treated him with painkillers to relieve
his pain and sedatives to slow his shakes. . He became weak and completely bedridden but
his mind was clear. One day, the pain became unbearable. She gave him injection
of pain medication. He begged Ona for more painkillers. When she hesitated, he
became angry.
“Don’t you see how much I suffer? How do you expect me to fight
the pain? Dying is a struggle. Give me
life that I can bear or let me go.” The
patient told her.
Ona wrote down a prescription for his pain. It was a concoction
of several drugs. She ordered a large
bottle of the mixture. Before she left the
patient, she told him,
“It is a strong medicine. Make sure, you only take one dose of
this every six to eight hours. More than that might kill you.”
Without waiting for an answer, she gently touched his forehead,
leaned over and kissed it.
“God bless you.” She said softly, turned around and quietly walked
out of the patient’s room.
Next morning patient’s wife found him dead in his bed. Next to
his bed was lying an empty bottle of the mixture, Ona had prescribed. The dead patient too kept haunting her in her
dreams.
I believe, Ona
was caught up at the end of her life not by its success but by things that she
thought were in the wrong. I tried to explain to her that no one should worry
about a life lived like the one she had. I told her that I was sorry that she
was dying so young and I would loose a good friend. I wondered why a woman of her talent and
goodness had to die. Now that she was on deathbed, she still struggled. Death,
for some, seems to be a battle.
Next day I
visited her again. My eyes were wet and my voice heavy. She looked at me and smiled
but I knew she did not know me. She kept saying things I did not understand.
Her eyes wandered and her voice trailed off in another world. I quietly left her room without even saying
good-bye to her.
© Copyright, V Amod Saxena, 2006