HOW A GOLF COURSE GOT ITS NAME
Stephen J. Schlegel
In the
1950s young boys would play in the forests on the far northwest side of
One family
lived on
In the
winters at very cold times, the river across the street would freeze flat. The family took special delight in crossing
down the embankment, setting up lanterns on the ice, skating with each other, neighbors
and friends, and returning to their homes for hot drinks and snacks. Although their homes were either brick or of
sound stone and wood construction, and heated with either oil or gas (in a few
cases still coal), they were enjoying some of the same outdoors experiences
along that river as their Indian ancestors did until 1835. That year, their Irish, Scots, and French
ancestors, amidst the booming development of the trading post called
The
Potawatomi tribes had communities that interacted first with the French traders
in the seventeenth century in
The French
had ceded the area including
There became a resistance we now call the
Pan-Indian Movement, spearheaded by Tecumseh. Potawatomi were recruited and associated with
raids as far south as southern
By
virtually all accounts, Billy, the son of a Mohawk woman, was born near
He was the product of his mother's
union with Senior Captain William Caldwell, of Walter Butler's Rangers, a
successor militia to the
Senior Captain Caldwell had
emigrated to the colonies and fought in battles in 1776, ‘77’ and ’78, and was
stationed as part of the Indian service in the area of Niagara. He was at
Although mother's name is not known to this day, all reports are that she was the daughter of a minor Mohawk chieftain named "Rising Sun", and that her refugee community, tended to by the British, moved from the Niagara region across to the Grand River in what is now Ontario. Baptised into the community as "Thomas" Caldwell, he was always known as "Billy". Although his grandfather, "Rising Sun" is not reported to comment, he must not have been too pleased when Senior Captain Caldwell deserted the community, his daughter, and his grandson, in 1782, when Billy was two.
Captain William Caldwell relocated
on the Canadian side at Amherstburg near
In 1783, he married Suzanne Baby, (B-A-B-Y). She was a proper, wealthy bourgeoise lady,
daughter of one Duperon Baby, a wealthy landowner and businessman. She was to
bear him eight children, but the laws of
Half brother William Jr. reported that while he was there, Billy acquired a "fair plain education." He learned ciphering and became literate and fluent in English, lost his natal Mohawk, and mastered a simple trader's French. Only years later, after tumultuous events, did Billy lapse to a trader's french dialect in some of his speaking and letters. His education was aimed at having him aid in the family farm acreage.
One researcher has reported:
"Put behind him was his Mohawkness, only to emerge in later years as a small emotional cancer, a despised and submerged fragment of his private identity, an element of nagging self-doubt that occasionally plagued him. In the years through 1797 he internalized as part of his own personality the sterling virtues of that frontier community -- a market mentality, loyalty to kin, economic independence, hard work, time-mindedness, acceptance of his place in an emerging hierarchical class system, and --and least in public --an unswerving obedience to constituted authority. Before the decade ended, he defined himself as a good Catholic, an Irishman, and --***a true Briton."
At home, however,
Billy had nothing to productively accomplish, especially in competition with
his half brothers that had the full attention and support of his father. So, at the age of 17, he became an apprentice
in the fur-trading business of John Forsyth, and was successful enough that he
traded through the
Both Forsyth and Kinzie were Scotsmen. Both fiercely independent, and prone to
exagerations. Both, however different
from Billy's father, were strong mentors and father figures to him, and he served
them well. By 1812 he had achieved such
trust of his employers, that Kinzie dispatched Billy to explain an affair in
which Kinzie had stabbed and killed a competitor in the shadow of
Forsyth and Kinzie had no regard
for the British, who were upsetting the Indian trade by sponsoring raiding
parties of Potawatomi against the colonists. Billy was a Brit, in the mold of his father,
but he was also an Indian; and he could relate as a clerk for the business, as
well as communicate and act as agent for the affairs of the local Potawatomi
and further extended tribal kinsmen throughout the Midwest at least as far as
the
1812 became
a big year in the life and legend of Billy Caldwell. Not only did he speak with the governor, it
was later reported by Kinzie's wife, now thought to be the fable of a social
climbing spouse of a brutal, yet influential founder of our city, that Billy
saved her and many others from death at the Fort Dearborn Massacre in August of
that year. It may have been that Billy
knew of the impending attack and may have urged the retreat of the American
patrol from the Fort, but contrary to Mrs. Kinzie’s report, the fact is that he
was in the Forsyth-Kinzie Emporium in
In the Fall
of 1812 Billy left the post and returned to Amherstburg where his family
remained, to enlist in the British service. His father was organizing a special force of
rangers and had secured commissions for his youngest sons. He did not extend that patronage to Billy,
however, who obtained for himself an appointment as captain in the British Indian Department. He served throughout the war, seeing combat in
January 1813. He was severely wounded by
an injured American officer who slashed Billy's throat although Billy was
actually trying to rescue the wounded American. He organized a successful raid on American
positions near
He then sought the position of
Assistant Deputy Superintendent General of the Indian Department for the
Western District. He was opposed for the
position by Indian Department officers who preferred his father for the
position, but he managed to gain and hold the position until he was discharged
in September 1816. For the next three
years, he unsuccessfully attempted to establish himself in businesses in
Amherstburg. Despite being his first
son, the good Captain successfully disinherited him in 1818. In 1820, Billy gave up trying, and emigrated
to the
What then, would this educated British Indian, come to do? What of the obvious suspicions that Chicagoans would have of this former British officer who had fought against the states in the war, organizing Indians to conduct raids on Americans? And what of the personality of this man, who had suffered the loss of his mother and Indian family identity a young age, worked hard to establish a true British identity through his youth in Amherstburg, yet suffered embarrassing lack of support and disinheritance by his revered British father, evidently in complicity with his step-mother? And why would it matter from an historical perspective?
What Billy
did do was establish himself as an educated, broadly experienced, ambitious
tradesman, and as a trustworthy American citizen. From 1820 to 1829 he worked hard as a merchant
and interpreter for Indian agents. In
1825 he was recommended for appointment as Justice of the Peace, and served as
an election commissioner the following year. In 1827 he accompanied an old Potawatomi
companion in arms named Shabni, to gather intelligence information in connection
with a Winnebago scare. In 1832, he
commanded a force of Potawatomi scouts during the Black Hawk affair, helping to
quell the uprising and keep Black Hawk from attempting to claim lands in
Throughout the 1820s he worked in association with his old employers, the Forsyths and Kinzies, as well as others who had recently risen to prominence in developing Chicago, especially the Indian agent Alexander Wolcott. Those relationships led to his American sponsored appointment as so-called "principal chief" of the Potawatomi tribes, and that involved him in negotiating the 1829 Treaty of Prairie du Chien. He continued to serve in that part-time capacity and he ably served his American employers through the end of the period. Most notably he acted in that capacity, actually as agent of the Indians although employed by the Americans, through the negotiations of the Treaty of Chicago of 1833. He was the only Indian signatory to that treaty who wrote his name, rather than his "mark" on the document.
He was rewarded for his efforts
with numerous cash payments, annuities, and land grants. The first and largest was two and one half
sections of "prime"
In 1835,
remaining Potawatomi in the area were required by the treaty of 1833 to leave
and move to reserved lands in western
Many of the details of Caldwell's life were unknown to historians until 1978, when James A. Clifton, Professor at the University of Wisconsin -- Green Bay, did exhaustive work uncovering letters of Billy Caldwell, documents from the Public Archives of Canada generated by the Indian Department and the Military, reported interviews with Caldwell's brothers from prior biographical sources, and delivered a paper on his life at the Annual Meeting of the American Historical Society in December, 1976.
Those
papers make it clear that Billy Caldwell had an understandable identity problem,
and suffered numerous addictions. Dr.
Miller's descriptions of the times of Caldwell in Chicago would have one note
that probably all of the early traders and Indians that dealt and inter-bred
with them were primarily interested in drinking, dancing and debauchery on the
frontier, and it took most of Caldwell's life before Chicago even Incorporated
as a City, in 1833. That, coincidentally,
was the year of the Treaty of Chicago primarily negotiated for the Indians by
Before he
died,
They include the neighborhood of Sauganash,
As early as
1869, a Dr. John Rauch formally suggested the formation of a Chicago Park
District, "to secure ample grounds for park purposes", which it had
failed to do, and which the good doctor suggested must be done to keep Chicago
an "attractive place of abode": in other words, "we want not
alone a place for business, but also one in which we can live", he said. As a result,
After the World's Fair of 1892-3, which awakened a new sense of municipal pride, the need for more park space was paramount, and the need to preserve natural areas was beginning to be recognized. Prominent architects Jens Jensen and Dwight H. Perkins, who later became the first president of the Chicago Regional Planning Commission, initiated a study, which concluded in 1904,
"Instead of acquiring space only the opportunity exists for preserving country naturally beautiful."
Among other
sites, the study identified the
"all of these
should be preserved for the benefit of the public in both the city and its
suburbs, and for their own sake and scientific value, which, if ever lost,
cannot be restored for generations. Another
reason for acquiring these outer areas is the necessity of providing for future
generations, which will extend to the borders of
The report seems remarkable because it was written at a time when public lands were still being dispersed by the federal government, and it foretold that future development in Cook County would extend all the way to the borders of the county, and beyond, and some of the areas described in the report were deemed by most to be so remote from the city the public would not be able to reach those areas to use them.
The president of the Cook County Board, Henry Foreman, became a forceful influence, but along a different vein, when he established the Outer Belt Commission to oversea the establishment of an outer belt of parks and boulevards, encircling the city and embracing the Calumet and DesPlaines Rivers and the Skokie Marsh. The difference in the respective propositions lies in "development of scenic highways" versus the preservation of lands of beauty in their natural state.
Two laws
were proposed to the State Legislature, one in 1905, said to be hastily drafted
and yet passed, which then Governor Deneen declared to be in "inoperative." The other one, in 1908, had substantial
public support due to the continuing efforts of Dwight Perkins and his
"Sunday Afternoon Walking Club," as well as the 1909 Burnham Plan,
which urged the preservation of forest lands surrounding
Finally, in
1913 an act was passed that stuck. In
1914, the residents of
The 1829 grant of 1600 acres to Billy Caldwell, surveyed as his "Reservation", minus the neighborhoods of Forest Glen, Sauganash, and Edgebrook, in which I grew up, became part of the Forest Preserve District of Cook County, and remain so today. Those acres, which include bicycle and hiking paths, two golf courses, "Edgebrook" (not a very good golf course) and "Billy Caldwell" (only nine holes, but fairly respectable), toboggan slides, a public swimming pool facility, picnic grounds, and square miles of grounds and woods on both sides of the Chicago river, which meanders through the plot. These acres are part of over 69,000 acres of the Forest Preserve District properties, the largest district of forest preserve lands in any county in the nation. They are governed by commissioners who are also the commissioners of the Cook County Board.
These conflicts of interest and concern over the management of Forest Preserve lands led to the establishment, in 1998, of a non-profit, primarily environmental organization, known as the Friends of the Forest Preserve District, which advocates for the preserves, and actively provides oversight for the District that is charged with preserving and protecting the lands. It has grown to include thousands of volunteer workers, and brought together the users of the preserves, including bikers, hikers, horseback riders, birders, golfers, and restoration and species preservation scientists from the Audubon Society, the Illinois Chapter of the Sierra Club, and other groups. It provides educational programs, restorational activities, as well as recreational activities.
Recently,
Ken Burns, the highly regarded documentary film maker, was in
Carl Birkelbach is currently, and wisely, talking in public and private of our obligations to preserve and restore district lands for "generations to come". The fact is that I was one of the "generations to come" of half-breed, misunderstood, misreported, suffering Billy Caldwell, although I have yet to find any Me'tis in my ancestry. The wisdom of those that decided to preserve and protect made my childhood and life thereafter enjoyable to a degree I have yet to fully recognize.
Each of the communities surrounding Billy Caldwell's reservation including the community of Edgebrook, have community historical associations. None had been fully aware of the life and times and contributions of Billy Caldwell, but thanks to the work of professor Christensen, who addressed the members of the Edgebrook Historical Association on March 19th this year, and who may be thanked for stimulating my interest in these matters, the work of the organizations dedicated to preserve and restore these lands will be motivated and continue to make the area a wonderful place to work, recreate, and rejoice in the natural, as well as the business activities of the community, with a view to generations to come, and with a perspective of what came before.
_________________________
This paper was presented at a regular meeting of the Chicago Literary Club on November 30, 2009.
_________________________
About the author: Mr.
Schlegel is a lifelong Chicagoan. He attended
He grew up in the Edgebrook neighborhood on
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Miller, Donald
L. City of the Century: The Epic of
2. Edmunds, David
R. “Potowatomis.” Encyclopedia of
3.
4. Gagnon, Jerry. “Billy Caldwell-Half Breed.” CaldwellGenealogy.com Discussion Forum. Posted 6/26/04. <http://caldwellgenealogy.com/forum/config.pl/noframes/read/1477>.
5. Gagnon, Jerry. “Billy Caldwell.” CaldwellGenealogy.com Discussion Forum. Posted 3/31/05. <http://caldwellgenealogy.com/forum/config.pl/noframes/read/1787>.
6.
7. “
8. “
9. “A Question of
Loyalties—Join or Die:
10. “William Caldwell (ranger).” Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 27 Nov. 2009. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Caldwell_(ranger)>.
11. “William Caldwell (ranger): Facts, Discussion Forum, and Encyclopedia Article.” AbsoluteAstronomy.com: Exploring the Universe of Knowledge. <http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/William_Caldwell_(ranger)>.
12. “Politics and
Politicians of
13. Nadig, Brian. “Facts Hard to Find on Life of Billy Caldwell.” Reporter. 21 Mar. 2009. <http://www.nadignewspapers.com/Pages/History/Billy%20Caldwell/Billy%20Caldwell.htm>.
14. “Monuments.” Early
15. “The Story of the Edgebrook Teepee.” <http://www.edgebrook.cps.k12.il.us/teepee.htm>.
16. McNichols, Mike,
ed. “Edgebrook – A Short History of
Edgebrook.”
17. “Billy Caldwell Golf Course.” Bing Local. 27 Nov. 2009. < http://www.bing.com/local/details.aspx?lid=YN272x189730202&qt=yp&what=billy+caldwell+golf+course&where=Chicago%2c+Illinois&s_cid=ansPhBkYp02&mkt=en-us&q=billy+caldwell+golf+course>.
18. “Chasing Billy Caldwell.” Readysubjects.org. <http://readysubjects.org/projects/chasingbilly/caldwell.html>.
19. Solzman, David
M. “
20. “The History of
21. “Sauganash.” Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 27 Nov. 2009. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billy_Caldwell>.
22. “
23. “Origins: The
Early History of the Forest Preserve District of
24. “About us.” Friends of the Forest Preserves – Advocates
for Nature and Recreation in