SIMPLE WITH BELLS ON
Paper presented to The Chicago
Literary Club
November 14, 2011
Florence D. McMillan
SIMPLE WITH BELLS ON
Simple is best. That axiom was coined before there were
coins, and it’s as true in today’s technological wonderland as it ever
was. “Simple is best” proves out not
only in every age, but every day in our professions and processes.
If your appendix inflames, the doctor
takes it out. Who needs it? It’s that simple.
When a banker contemplates a simple
interest transaction, it’s a simple matter; however, a complex-compound rate is
a horse of a different color, especially when Wall Street rides it.
The genius of Thomas Edison was his
ability to focus his vision on simplicity.
The story goes that when his scientific colleagues began to quibble and
dither over the harnessing of light in a bulb, he cried, “damn it, I’m trying
to INVENT something!”
What could be simpler than the
proverbial mouse trap? A cheap
guillotine loaded with a cow’s milk teaser.
Man’s quest for natural resources has
always been marked by the simplest way to get at them:
1.The funneling of water through a trough
of wood or
bamboo.
2. Power for our labor with the aid of a windmill.
3. Strip mining: What you see is what you get.
Inventions,
even space ships, usually evolve from complicated to simple: The radio to the transistor, the IBM
mainframe to the Apple laptop, the airwave to the Cloud.
The farmer’s
combine, a harvesting machine, was so called because it combined an ingenious,
but complicated set of fallible steps.
As it moved, it lifted cut stalks of grain into rows of large spikes
into a series of twelve galvanized tin sieves.
Paddles beat on the grain stalks until the chaff fell through the sieves
and out onto the ground. Kernels in the
pans rose on a stack of metal plates into a huge box where a funnel dumped them
into a moving truck. Not simple – with a
lot of moving parts to break down. Spit
and twine will only go so far.
To inspect a
brand new $300,000 dollar combine today,
you stick your head through a small door in this red behemoth and see nothing
inside but one screw, a very large, very red augur with graduated holes on each
flange. How simple can you get?
And then we
put the bells on. The mousetrap morphs
into a small hotel of a dazzling design in shocking pink, irresistible to the
rodent. Apple has added “apps” to waste
our time at work and play. The combine
has added tinted glass, music in sensurround, and a microwave for snacks.
And the
Hillbilly Clampett family have deserted the hills of Beverly, oil profits in
hand, to lounge in their new CE – ment pond.
The golden dinner bell rings from Beverly Hills to the Plains of North
Dakota.
This is the
story of the Bakken Field, a rich lode of crude oil in the larger Williston
basin in western North Dakota. The Field
is named after Mr. Bakken, a Norwegian immigrant grain farmer with 300 acres,
who farmed the land at the turn of the century.
The oil has
been there for as long as conceivable time.
It was there as the Rockies were forming. It was there when the Northern Pacific
Railway imported thousands of men from China to build track. It was there when I studied it in sixth grade
in Casselton, North Dakota and learned that it was so deep in rock shale that
it could never be recovered.
Its
possibilities were largely ignored until 1953, when some exploratory drilling
was done by Amerada Oil Company and given up as a lost cost. The company (like my mother) bought leasing
rights to substantial acreage, which they held into the late 70’s – alas, not
long enough.
After 50
years of minimal exploratory interest in this enormous pig in a poke, a
technology to enable the recovery of crude oil from this rock formation, a kind
of preCambrian sagging, is now in place. The greater Williston Basin began to
develop almost two billion years ago.
The oval shaped area comprises about 500 square miles, or 350,000 acres,
more than three times the size of the King Ranch in Texas. Drilling is spread out, however, and so often
economically feasible. Use of federal
lands in Montana is prohibited by U.S. law.
The Bakken
is a smaller, highly concentrated oil field, mostly in North Dakota. It is not an oil trap like the Elm Coulee
basin in Montana, but a large area of subterranean oil which can be mined with
today’s tools. Indeed, the appropriate
analogy is to the strip mining of coal in West Virginia. In 2004 the U.S. geological Study estimated
that the Bakken Field contained four billion barrels of crude oil. In 2008 they revised that figure to eleven
barrels. In 2010 the estimate was 22
billion barrels. Harold Hamm, CEO of
Continental Resources, the largest oil company presence in the Bakken, who
estimated that the entire Bakken Field, fully developed, would yield 24
billion barrels turned out to be right. That
number is now considered to represent ultimate recovery in the Bakken
Field. Such a staggering amount of
recoverable crude oil will change western North Dakota forever, not to mention
consumption, distribution, and financial machinations in the entire country. As of this moment, November 2011, North
Dakota is producing 450,000 barrels a day; Montana, 50,000. Montana has nine new rigs(wells) . North Dakota is currently opening 167 new
wells a month . (This figure includes
the initial drilling of 2000 “confidential
wells” for which state permits have been issued. These wells are not recognized until six months
after the first fracking. It is expected
that by 2020, 700,000 barrels per day will be extracted from the Bakken and
Montana, more than the daily production of Saudi Arabia’s largest field.
As for
movements. layers, and shifting sediments, we still have a world to learn about
the geological and graphical underpinnings of the Great Plains. Recovery figures from the Bakken Field and
recent success of drilling efforts there reflect the guesstimates experts are
making about formations that lie tens of thousands of feet below them. One thing we DO know – the oil is stuck in
shale. The formations were created one
to two billion years ago by continual receding and advancing seas, which produced
shale layers of 1,000 up to 15,000 feet thick.
The geological makeup of the Bakken Field is comprised of three members,
or layers. The first layer, which sits
under one mile of ordinary ground (as in ground water) is shale, so dense as to
be nearly impenetrable. It is about a
mile thick. The middle layer is composed of silty dolostone, a permeable
mixture of gravel, sand, and silicate (ceramic). This layer contains crude oil. It is variously four to one thousand feet thick. The lower layer is again shale, which
contains siltstone. The layers have been
described as an Oreo cookie in which the “chocolate” layers compress the
middle, “frosting” layer, which is composed of porous, malleable elements.
The
vocabulary of the extraction endeavor is as rich and colorful as that of your
favorite sports commentator. For example
I give you:
CRUDE –
crude is oil, never natural gas, which is found in the Marcellus in
Pennsylvania and in Louisiana, Monterey, Alaska.
“THE PLAY” –
an oil well coming into its own
“RIG” – a
well. The rigs, above the ground, look
like hundreds of small, roaming dinosaurs.
“LATERAL” –
a horizontal drilling line. A short
lateral is one mile,; a long lateral is two, and so on.
“PLUG AND
PERF” – a complicated blasting method involving perforation
“SLIDING
SLEEVE” – a blasting device like the tube which returned your change through
pneumatic routing at Macy’s in the 1940’s.
Current preferred method. Simple
is best.
“HYDRAULIC
FRACTURING” – blasting followed by the application of water pressure
“FRACKING” –
slang for the above
“FRAC FLUID”
– a mixture of water, sand, silicate (ceramic), gel, and trace chemicals
“STIMULATE’
– introduce frac fluid onto fractured middle layer to encourage the movement of
oil. Term often used by the oil lobby
“HOSE OUT” –
term used by oil workers for this process
“TAKE AWAY
CAPACITY” – realistic estimate of barrels that can be brought up and
distributed
“SHUT IN
WELLS” – closed by outside influences which impede production
“CAP A WELL”
– take a producing well out of production.
Capping and recapping are illegal in North Dakota
“DRILLING
OUT PLUG” – unplugging the well to release pressured oil. Also known as “Come to PaPa”
“IP” –
initial production of oil in the first 24 hours of a new well
HOW DO THEY DO IT?
Like the folks at International Harvester who simplified from
twelve sieves to one big, red screw, the R&D oil guys refined process in
the simplest way imaginable. They
thought about that Oreo cookie, and they started drilling NOT down, but
sideways. It’s as simple as that – and
much more important than a better mousetrap.
When drilling a well vertically, oil monkeys must make 6000 holes
through a mile or two of the densest shale.
The simple way is to drill vertically ONCE, make an “L” turn with the
bore and “lateral” horizontally right through the frosting layer. The first lateral, drilled in 1987, was one
mile long. As I speak, a 60 mile lateral
is being bored. To produce six wells,
serial laterals, parallel laterals, even trilaterals are drilled over a field
of 1280 acres ( a square mile – from the Cliff Dwellers north to Navy Pier then
west to Halsted Street and South back to 200 South Michigan). in 30-60 stages or intervals every 15 feet
until kingdom come. The sight of a well
SITE is an awesome thing. There are
several of those little dinosaur rigs.
There are tinkers(about 50 men and the occasional woman), trailers,
trucks, cranes, computers and cable.
Lots of cable.
You take the oil out of the cookie by a blasting process
known as “fracking”. Here is the cable:
a roll of dental floss. Here is a plug,
a capsule pill. Inside is explosive –
the magic powder the doctor gives me. A
specialized worker “perfs” the capsule, drilling holes. The capsules are threaded onto cable at
measured intervals, like the pearls on Madam’s necklace, and lowered through
the shorter vertical entry. The first
capsule is guided by the most complex software and the steadiest hand on the
throttle to make the “L” shaped turn and start its journey to the very end of
the lateral, which could be three miles.
Every 15 feet after that another capsule is “dropped off” from its
skin. The precision required for these
computerized placements is an impressive combination of focus, touch, and
intellect.
Last Christmas the oil monkeys got a simple gift. Someone thought of a “sliding sleeve”. No more “perfs”! When each capsule is dropped off, the computer
slides it open, like moving the slide on a salt shaker. Simple is best.
When this necklace of perhaps 400 capsules is laid out in the
frosting, one man at one console in one trailer pushes the button. The field is quiet as a tomb. Just over there, by the rig, a man hugs an
iron pipe like a lover. When he feels a
tremor, he shouts; and the blast three miles beneath is completed in utter
silence.
At the site of each capsule the silty dolostone middle,
porous level – and some shale as well – has been “fracked”, the fractures
webbing out to release the flow of oil.
Immediately, up above, the crew begins to pump a mixture of water,
chemical gel, and sand, under pressure through the lateral. The oil, already viscous, thins and flows
toward the location of the “drilled out plug”.
The sand presses against the fracture to hold it open for continued oil
flow. The “frac fluid” separates from
the oil and is sluiced off near ground level.
It’s so simple. I can get you a
job in North Dakota!
COSTS AND TRADE OFFS
Money has been saved, and in huge quantities, through the now
refined processes of horizontal drilling.
The sliding sleeve alone has shortened the time needed for lateral
placement from seven days to 24 hours, and cut the cost of Manual labor in
half.
Harold Hamm, CEO of Continental Resources, the largest oil
presence in the Bakken Field, estimates that vertical drilling over an area of
one square mile would produce only 20% of what horizontal drilling can “take
away”.
And HOW MUCH IS that, exactly? The life or “decline rate” of a well drilled
in the Bakken to date is ten to fifteen years at current production, which is
high. The total life of one of these
wells is up to 40 years, aided by refracking and innovation. In its life a Bakken well could produce
300,000 (Volken- CEO/WLL) to 500,000 (Hamm- CEO/CR) barrels.
A word to the wise:
Oil monkeys use terms like “sweet spot” and “crazy numbers” and “tell
me” IPs (that first 24 hours). A
self-reported initial production figure is seldom meaningful. An oil company’s published IP estimate is
usually about half of the driller’s. The
latest new well record, confirmed, is 7009 barrels on November 3, 2011.
COST CONSIDERATIONS
The completion and drilling of one well costs ten million
dollars.
Ten million dollars buys a day’s heat for half a million
homes.
Which is better for America?
An oil well or a ten million dollar mansion in Easthampton?
You can ship oil to New York City more easily from North
Dakota than from Kuwait. Or can you?
At the end of the 19th century, when fortunes were
in the ground, North Dakota was a simple, fertile, promising new state. There were no hills, one and a half lakes,
some shelterbelt trees planted by CCC crews in the thirties.
There was oil, but you couldn’t get at it. It was secondary to the real cash crop: Wheat, barley, flax, corn. Secondary by far to the Northern Pacific, the
Great Northern, the rails that carried America’s natural riches from West to
East and back again. Oil for the
engines. Wheat for hungry mouths. It was perfectly simple.
Today the challenges to North Dakota and its oil are
infrastructure, distribution, and weather.
There’s an old farmer’s saying:
“The wet days will scare you to death, but the winters will freeze you
to death.” Thirty-five to forty degree
below zero is not an uncommon temperature in any part of North Dakota. A person who ventures outside will burn his
lungs to a crisp. The Bakken Field is
closed to drilling from November through March.
This virtually extends the life of a confidential well permit to one
year after fracking. Shut-in wells mean
lost revenue for 25% of the year. Capped
wells are illegal in North Dakota. They
prevent production from exceeding take away capacity, which keeps the price of
crude oil up; a solution the state does not consider viable.
The problems
of distribution and delivery that plagued early cattlemen have come back to
haunt the new cowboys, the Hess, Halliburton,CR gang. Pipelines will come…..but When? And How?
For the
moment trucking is the most available and affordable method of delivery. The Interstate goes straight across North
Dakota from border to border without a hill or curve. Rail is a better alternative; IF the tracks
are serviceable, IF the roadbeds are somewhat functional, IF tank cars can drop
off at refinery sidings or, better yet, onto Great Lakes barges. IF the federal government will subsidize to
the tune of billions.
A barrel of
Bakken crude sells for $93.11, but $12 less when oil produced exceeds capacity
to ship. By May ,2012 three North Dakota
towns will have constructed rail terminals which can ship 60,000 barrels daily
in a train of one hundred tank cars. As
a result many of the Bakken’s “confidential
wells” have gone into play, increasing per diem production by 110,000 barrels.
And now, the
moment you’ve been waiting for –
SAFETY AND POLLUTION ISSUES
On maps,
ironically, the icons representing oil wells drilled in the Bakken Field look
like little green pine trees. Almost no
major environmental organization has failed to show its interest in the
development of the Bakken area. Public
opinion and comment on the implications for pollution and harmful effects range
from concern to paranoia. So let me try to make it simple – without the
bells. Certain facts are apparent and
confirmed: Fear that the oil will contaminate
water supplies or rivers are unfounded because the oil is buried too deeply to
affect water supply. The top of the
cookie, the dense slate layer, which is itself one to two miles thick, has over
time been sealed from a mile of layers ABOVE it, which we call “ground”, as in
“ground water”.
The danger
of water contamination resides in failure to appropriately contain the fracking
fluid residue, which includes additive fluids and trace chemical elements. Reservoirs which hold these fluids are called
“ponds” and can be very large. They must
be lined effectively to “seal” the ponds in order to prevent contamination.
Jed Clampett
didn’t have the cleanest “CE – ment pond” in Beverly Hills, and neither does
the oil industry. Specific regulations regarding
the containment of these ponds are sketchy and poorly described. At present environmental groups are left on
their own to blow the whistle. Like the
report of a three year old who says, “I’ve picked up my room,” the industry’s
margin of error is high. And where IS
Mother, anyway?
Methane, or
natural gas, is a light, invisible, vaporous form of oil which comes from the
layers above the Bakken shale. It is not
connected to the fracking process. It is
a contaminant only when produced in the layer of ground water. In the Powder River Basin in Wyoming, which
contains a lot of methane vapor, if you order a whiskey and water in a bar, it
will turn black.
Methane in
the ground water is a byproduct of the more lucrative “sweet oil” in the Bakken
Field. It is very difficult to stuff
methane back into the ground. So the oil
producers do the simple thing. They burn
it off. The process is called “flaring”
and is a legitimate target of environmentalists. Thirty percent of the natural gas which
arises in the Bakken is flared off. The
nightly sight makes a forest fire look like a campfire.
When one
asks about the adverse effects of flaring on the environment, the silence is
deafening. Put your ear to the ground
and you’ll smell the gas before you’ll hear a sound. The Natural Gas lobby admits in the New
York Times that “flaring is a
problem.” The oil lobby refers
repeatedly to a plea for “a conducive regularity environment”. The Governor of North Dakota says, “We’re
watching flaring very carefully.”
The truth is
that the wasted natural gas isn’t worth the trouble. The oil monkeys can’t even get the sweet oil
out as fast as they’d like.
It would be
simple of everything were the oil’s fault, but it is nonproductive to blame the
source or the process. Farmer Bakken
could have simply run those oil monkeys off with a shotgun, but he’s not in
charge anymore. Who is? Environmentalists? Industry?
Man? Who will regulate the
combined, complex solutions required to keep water and air supplies clean?
The problems
couldn’t be simpler: Recovery, Disposal,
Transportation, Safeguards, BUT
When the
going gets tough,
When the
riches are uncovered,
When the
stakes go up,
When we’re
cold,
When we want
to drive to the Mall,
When we go
to the polls,
That’s where
the buck stops.
After that,
it gets complicated.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Collins,
Laura. “Desperately Seeking Dalrymple”
New York Times,October 6, 2011.
Konisberg,
Eric. “Kuwait on the Prairie,” The
New Yorker, April 25, 2011
Moore,Stephen. “How North Dakota Became Saudi Arabia.” Wall
Street Journal, October 1, 2011
United
States Geological Surveys. Production estimates 2004-2008
Wikipedia:
Production estimates, maps
This
American Life. Podcast #444
Million
Dollar Way (All Bakken All the Time): Blog, November 10,
2011
Kramer, Jim. The Street, broadcast CNBC, August
22,2011
Energy
Policy Research Foundation, Inc.: Presentation at
energy forum: New York City, May 19,
2011
EPRINC: “Bakken Shale Output – Supply Implications
for North Dakota,” May, 2011
EPRINC: “The Bakken Boom”, August 3, 2011
Interview
with Dr. Judith L. Hamilton, geologist, hydro engineer, consultant-FEMA.
May 21,2011
Interviews
with Ian R. Nathan, Senior Research Analyst, Energy Intelligence Research, Inc.
July 6, 2011, September 14, 2011
Interview
with William Kent, William Kent Associates, Hawley, Pennsylvania, October, 2009. For information concerning natural gas in the
Marcellus Shale